C-sections and Mental Health

Each year on National C-Section Day, January 14th, we recognize the vital role cesarean deliveries (C-sections) play in modern childbirth. These procedures save countless lives and are sometimes the safest option for both parent and baby. However, as a practice focused on reproductive mental health, we feel it is crucial to understand the nuanced relationship between C-sections and maternal mental health. This relationship will be different based on different situations, beliefs, indications and many other factors. 

Understanding C-Sections and Their Impact

A C-section is a surgical procedure used to deliver a baby through incisions in the abdomen and uterus. While it is often life-saving, the physical and emotional recovery process can be more complex than with a vaginal delivery. C-sections are major surgery! Globally, the rate of C-sections is rising, with significant variation across regions and medical systems.

For many expectant parents, a planned or unplanned C-section can bring feelings of relief and gratitude, especially when the health of the baby or mother is at risk. However, for others, it may trigger mixed emotions, including feelings of loss, disappointment, or even trauma. This is especially true for emergency c-sections or for c-sections which were not desired by the birthing parent. 

C-Sections and Postpartum Mental Health

Research, including a study published in BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth (referenced article), has shown that C-sections can have varying effects on maternal mental health:

• Increased Risk of Postpartum Depression (PPD): Some studies indicate that women who have C-sections, particularly emergency ones, may face a slightly higher risk of PPD. As with other forms of birth trauma, factors contributing to this include feelings of loss of control during labor and unmet expectations about the birthing process. Additionally, physical recovery challenges also make it much harder for birthing parents to care for themself, which we know is a risk factor for PPD.  
• Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD): Traumatic birth experiences, including emergency C-sections, can result in PTSD for some women. Symptoms include flashbacks, avoidance behaviors, and heightened anxiety, which may impact bonding with the baby. This is an incredibly over-simplified glance at this topic–for more information on birth trauma we recommend following Kayleigh Summers, LCSW, PMH-C on IG! 
• Positive Mental Health Outcomes: On the other hand, planned C-sections can alleviate anxiety for some women with specific medical concerns or prior traumatic birthing experiences. For these mothers, the predictability of a scheduled procedure can be empowering and helpful.

Cultural and Societal Influences

In many cultures, C-sections carry stigma, with societal pressures favoring vaginal births as the “natural” or “ideal” method. I’ve even heard of women being told they “didn’t give birth” because they had a C-section! This judgment can lead to feelings of guilt or inadequacy in mothers who undergo a C-section, further impacting mental health. If you’re a C-section parent please know this is not true at all! 

Supporting Mothers Post-C-Section

Given the diverse experiences of C-section mothers, support must be individualized and holistic.

1. Acknowledge Emotional Recovery: Healthcare providers and loved ones should validate that emotional recovery is just as important as physical healing. Listening to mothers' feelings without judgment is key. If you’re a support person for a C-section parent be their advocate at their side during delivery and in the postpartum period!
2. Encourage Mental Health Resources: Therapy, support groups, and resources tailored to postpartum mental health can help mothers process their experiences and seek support. We find the groups at Postpartum Support International to be consistently helpful for some of our patients. 
3. Foster Community/Use Your Voice: Platforms where birthing parents share their C-section stories can help normalize the experience and reduce stigma. The groups mentioned above can also provide some benefit in this arena.
4. Advocate for Comprehensive Postpartum Care: Policies that prioritize maternal mental health, such as access to perinatal therapists (like ours!), extended parental leave, and education about birth trauma, are essential.

Final Thoughts

C-sections are an incredible medical advancement that has saved countless lives. However, like all aspects of childbirth, they come with complexities that deserve recognition. By fostering an open, supportive dialogue about the mental health impact of C-sections, we can ensure that all parents feel validated, empowered, and supported in their postpartum journeys.

On this National C-Section Day, let’s celebrate the resilience of birthing people everywhere and commit to creating a culture where their physical and mental health are equally prioritized!

‍